Beyond the Crown: A Deep Dive into the Illustrious 2016 Motor Trend Car of the Year Contenders

Beyond the Crown: A Deep Dive into the Illustrious 2016 Motor Trend Car of the Year Contenders Typestruck.Guidemechanic.com

The automotive world is a realm of constant innovation, breathtaking design, and fierce competition. Every year, enthusiasts and industry experts eagerly await the pronouncements of prestigious awards that highlight the pinnacle of automotive engineering and artistry. Among these, the Motor Trend Car of the Year (COTY) stands as a beacon, recognizing vehicles that push boundaries and redefine expectations.

In 2016, the competition was particularly intense, showcasing a diverse lineup of vehicles that ranged from everyday heroes to groundbreaking technological marvels and pure performance machines. This wasn’t just a race for a trophy; it was a testament to the industry’s dynamism. Join us as we journey back to explore the formidable contenders that vied for the coveted 2016 Motor Trend Car of the Year title, examining what made each one a standout and why this particular year remains a fascinating case study in automotive excellence.

Beyond the Crown: A Deep Dive into the Illustrious 2016 Motor Trend Car of the Year Contenders

Understanding the Prestige: What Defines the Motor Trend Car of the Year Award?

Before we delve into the contenders, it’s crucial to understand the rigorous criteria that underpin the Motor Trend Car of the Year award. This isn’t merely a popularity contest; it’s a comprehensive evaluation process designed to identify truly exceptional vehicles. Motor Trend’s expert team subjects dozens of new or significantly updated models to a battery of tests, both on the track and in real-world driving conditions.

The judging process focuses on six key criteria, each vital to a vehicle’s overall success and impact. These pillars guide the evaluators in making their ultimate decision, ensuring that the chosen vehicle represents a holistic package of excellence.

The Six Key Criteria for Motor Trend’s COTY:

1. Advancement in Design: This criterion assesses the vehicle’s exterior and interior aesthetics, its functionality, and how effectively it pushes visual boundaries while remaining practical. It’s about more than just looking good; it’s about intelligent design that enhances the user experience.
2. Engineering Excellence: Judges scrutinize the innovation in the vehicle’s powertrain, chassis, suspension, and overall construction. This involves evaluating the materials used, the efficiency of the engine, and the sophistication of its mechanical and electronic systems.
3. Efficiency: This pillar covers not just fuel economy but also the efficiency of the vehicle’s footprint, its material usage, and its overall environmental impact. It’s about getting more from less, whether it’s power, space, or resources.
4. Safety: Beyond crash test ratings, this criterion looks at active and passive safety features, driver-assistance technologies, and how well the vehicle protects its occupants and helps prevent accidents. Modern safety is proactive, not just reactive.
5. Value: This isn’t simply about the lowest price tag. Value considers the purchase price relative to the vehicle’s performance, features, quality, and expected depreciation. It’s about what the buyer gets for their money in the long run.
6. Performance of Intended Function: Perhaps the most crucial criterion, this evaluates how well the vehicle fulfills its primary purpose. A sports car should excel at driving dynamics, while a family sedan should prioritize comfort and practicality. It’s about delivering on promises.

Based on my experience observing these awards over the years, the "Performance of Intended Function" often serves as the tie-breaker. A car might be beautifully designed and technologically advanced, but if it doesn’t perform its core duties exceptionally well, it struggles to clinch the top spot.

The Crucible of 2016: A Look at the Diverse Contenders

The 2016 Motor Trend Car of the Year competition brought together a truly eclectic mix of vehicles, each representing the cutting edge of its segment. From nimble roadsters to luxurious sedans, and from groundbreaking eco-cars to muscular American icons, the field was ripe with innovation. This diversity made for a fascinating comparison, highlighting the different directions the automotive industry was heading.

Each contender brought its unique strengths to the table, showcasing advancements in technology, design, and driving dynamics. The judges had their work cut out for them, tasked with comparing apples to oranges, yet finding the common thread of excellence. Let’s delve into the specific vehicles that made it to the prestigious finalist round.

1. Audi TT: The Style Icon’s Reimagination

The third-generation Audi TT arrived in 2016 with a sharper, more aggressive design and a host of technological upgrades, reaffirming its status as a premium compact sports coupe. It retained its iconic silhouette but infused it with a modern edge, particularly with its striking LED lighting signatures.

Underneath its sculpted skin, the TT boasted Audi’s sophisticated Virtual Cockpit, a digital instrument cluster that completely transformed the driver’s interface. This innovative display consolidated all necessary information, including navigation and infotainment, directly in front of the driver, enhancing both focus and usability. This was a significant step forward in automotive interior design, setting a trend for future luxury vehicles.

While lauded for its exquisite interior, precise handling, and advanced Quattro all-wheel-drive system, the TT faced stiff competition from more performance-focused or utilitarian rivals. Its primary focus remained on style and driver engagement, perhaps less on groundbreaking efficiency or family practicality. However, for sheer aesthetic appeal and technological polish, the TT was a strong contender.

2. BMW 7 Series: The Flagship of Innovation

BMW’s sixth-generation 7 Series represented a monumental leap forward for the brand’s flagship luxury sedan. It was a technological tour de force, packed with innovations designed to redefine the luxury car experience. Key among these was its Carbon Core construction, which strategically incorporated carbon fiber reinforced plastic (CFRP) to reduce weight without compromising structural rigidity.

Inside, the 7 Series was a sanctuary of opulence and high-tech features. Gesture Control allowed occupants to manage infotainment functions with simple hand movements, while the Executive Lounge Seating option offered unparalleled rear-seat comfort, complete with reclining seats and massage functions. Its air suspension system delivered an incredibly smooth ride, insulating passengers from road imperfections.

Despite its impressive array of technologies and luxurious appointments, the 7 Series faced the challenge of demonstrating "Performance of Intended Function" against a field that included more visceral driving machines. While it excelled at its luxury mission, its significant price tag and focus on rear-seat indulgence meant it wasn’t for everyone. It showcased engineering brilliance, but perhaps not universal appeal for the COTY title.

3. Chevrolet Camaro: The Reinvention of an Icon

The sixth-generation Chevrolet Camaro was a revelation, shedding significant weight and adopting a more sophisticated chassis derived from the Cadillac ATS. This transformation brought a level of agility and refinement previously unseen in the muscle car. It wasn’t just about straight-line speed anymore; it was about balanced performance.

Motor Trend specifically praised the Camaro for its vastly improved driving dynamics, precise steering, and powerful engine options, which included a new 2.0-liter turbo, a V6, and the potent V8. The interior also received a much-needed overhaul, with higher-quality materials and improved ergonomics, though some critics still found outward visibility challenging. Its design was both evolutionary and revolutionary, clearly a Camaro but with a modern, athletic stance.

This car exemplified a commitment to engineering excellence and performance of intended function. It took an American icon and made it globally competitive, delivering a thrilling driving experience without sacrificing its heritage. The judges were particularly impressed with how thoroughly Chevrolet had re-engineered the platform.

4. Chevrolet Malibu: The Mainstream Challenger

The 2016 Chevrolet Malibu marked a significant redesign for the brand’s midsize sedan, aiming to reclaim market share from established Japanese rivals. It boasted a longer wheelbase, resulting in improved rear-seat legroom, and a sleeker, more upscale exterior design that gave it a premium look.

Under the hood, the Malibu offered a new 1.5-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine, focusing on efficiency, alongside a more powerful 2.0-liter turbo option. It also introduced a hybrid variant, showcasing Chevrolet’s commitment to diverse powertrain options. The interior was modern and comfortable, equipped with Chevrolet’s MyLink infotainment system and advanced safety features.

While the Malibu represented a substantial improvement over its predecessor, offering good value and a comfortable ride, it faced the formidable task of standing out in the hyper-competitive midsize sedan segment. It was a strong, well-rounded performer, but perhaps lacked the specific "wow" factor or revolutionary aspect that some other contenders brought to the table.

5. Honda Civic: The Game Changer for the Masses

The tenth-generation Honda Civic was arguably one of the most anticipated and significant new cars of 2016. Honda completely reimagined its compact cornerstone, giving it a daring, fastback-inspired design that was a radical departure from previous generations. This bold aesthetic was matched by an equally impressive engineering overhaul.

Crucially, the 2016 Civic introduced Honda’s first-ever turbocharged engine in a mainstream model for North America, a 1.5-liter unit that offered an excellent blend of power and fuel efficiency. The new platform provided a more refined ride, sharper handling, and a remarkably spacious and well-appointed interior, loaded with technology like Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. This car truly redefined what a compact car could be.

Based on my experience, the Civic’s transformation was a masterclass in re-establishing a brand icon. It offered exceptional value, groundbreaking design for its segment, and genuinely enjoyable driving dynamics, making it a powerful contender for the overall award. It excelled in "Performance of Intended Function" for a mass-market compact car.

6. Kia Optima: The Stylish Value Proposition

The 2016 Kia Optima presented a more refined and mature evolution of its stylish midsize sedan, building on the success of its predecessor’s design. While the exterior changes were subtle, they enhanced the car’s premium feel, particularly with its signature "tiger nose" grille and sleek lines.

Inside, Kia focused on improving material quality, ergonomics, and technology, offering a more driver-centric cabin. It also introduced a new 1.6-liter turbocharged engine paired with a 7-speed dual-clutch transmission, adding another layer of efficiency and responsiveness to its powertrain lineup. The Optima continued to offer an impressive array of features for its price point.

The Optima consistently delivers strong value and an attractive package. While it might not have pushed the boundaries of automotive engineering as dramatically as some rivals, its steady improvement in design, quality, and feature content made it a compelling option. It demonstrated excellent "Value" and solid "Advancement in Design" within its segment.

7. Mazda MX-5 Miata: The Pure Driving Joy Machine

The fourth-generation Mazda MX-5 Miata, affectionately known as the "ND," was a return to roots for the iconic roadster. Mazda meticulously engineered it to be lighter, smaller, and even more driver-focused than its predecessors. This commitment to lightweight simplicity was a refreshing counter-trend in an industry often focused on adding features and size.

The 2016 Miata delivered an unparalleled sense of connection between driver and road, with its perfectly balanced chassis, direct steering, and slick manual transmission. Its 2.0-liter naturally aspirated engine, while not overwhelmingly powerful, was eager to rev and perfectly matched to the car’s nimble character. This car was all about the joy of driving.

Pro tips from us: when evaluating a car like the Miata, remember that "Performance of Intended Function" is paramount. It’s not about practicality or raw speed, but about delivering an unadulterated, engaging driving experience. The Miata absolutely nailed this, earning widespread critical acclaim for its purity and fun factor.

8. Mercedes-Benz C-Class: The Compact Luxury Standard-Bearer

The Mercedes-Benz C-Class Coupe, based on the highly acclaimed W205 C-Class sedan, brought a new level of sophistication and style to the compact luxury segment. It showcased Mercedes’ evolving design language, with sleek lines, a dynamic profile, and a truly opulent interior that mirrored elements of the larger S-Class.

Under the hood, the C-Class Coupe offered a range of powerful yet refined engines, paired with advanced suspension systems that delivered a composed and comfortable ride, typical of Mercedes-Benz. Its advanced infotainment system, premium materials, and array of safety technologies cemented its position as a serious contender in the luxury space. It blended performance with a sense of occasion.

While a beautiful and highly capable car, the C-Class Coupe, like the BMW 7 Series, operated in a specific luxury niche. Its appeal was strong within its segment, but the overall COTY award often favors vehicles with broader impact or more revolutionary approaches. Nevertheless, its "Advancement in Design" and "Engineering Excellence" were undeniable.

9. Nissan Maxima: The "Four-Door Sports Car" Reborn

The 2016 Nissan Maxima aimed to reclaim its "four-door sports car" moniker with a dramatic redesign that infused it with aggressive styling and a more engaging driving experience. Its bold V-Motion grille, floating roof effect, and sculpted body panels made it one of the most visually distinctive sedans on the market.

Power came from a revised 3.5-liter V6 engine, now producing 300 horsepower, paired with a continuously variable transmission (CVT) that was specifically tuned for more spirited driving. The interior received a substantial upgrade, featuring premium materials, a driver-focused cockpit, and Nissan’s latest infotainment system, positioning it as a near-luxury offering.

The Maxima made a strong statement with its design and performance, striving to offer a unique blend of sportiness and practicality. However, the inherent limitations of a front-wheel-drive platform and the perception of a CVT in a "sports car" could have been points of contention for some judges. It certainly pushed the boundaries of what a mainstream Nissan sedan could be.

10. Toyota Mirai: The Hydrogen Pioneer

The Toyota Mirai was arguably the most forward-thinking and technologically ambitious contender in the 2016 lineup. As a hydrogen fuel cell electric vehicle (FCEV), it represented a bold step into alternative propulsion, emitting only water vapor. This car was a testament to Toyota’s commitment to sustainable mobility.

The Mirai’s engineering excellence was undeniable, featuring a complex fuel cell stack that converted hydrogen into electricity to power an electric motor. Its design was certainly polarizing, reflecting its futuristic technology, and the interior was equally distinctive, emphasizing its eco-conscious mission. It offered a smooth, silent electric driving experience with quick refueling times, a significant advantage over battery-electric vehicles at the time.

Common mistakes to avoid are underestimating the impact of truly innovative vehicles like the Mirai, even if their market reach is initially limited. While its "Efficiency" and "Engineering Excellence" were off the charts, its extremely limited infrastructure and high cost meant it wasn’t a practical choice for most buyers, which likely impacted its "Value" and "Performance of Intended Function" for the general public.

The Winner: Chevrolet Camaro – A Masterclass in Reinvention

After rigorous testing and deliberation, the 2016 Motor Trend Car of the Year award was bestowed upon the Chevrolet Camaro. This victory was a clear affirmation of Chevrolet’s comprehensive efforts to reinvent an American icon, transforming it from a brute-force muscle car into a sophisticated, world-class performance machine.

The Camaro’s win underscored its significant advancements across multiple COTY criteria. Its new Alpha platform provided exceptional chassis dynamics, delivering handling precision and ride quality that rivaled premium European sports coupes. The diverse engine lineup, from the efficient turbo-four to the mighty V8, offered compelling options for a wide range of buyers, while the interior saw a dramatic improvement in design and material quality. It was a complete package.

The judges particularly lauded its "Engineering Excellence" and how well it performed its "Intended Function" as an exhilarating, driver-focused sports car. It retained its iconic muscle car identity but added a layer of refinement and agility that made it genuinely competitive on a global stage. The 2016 Camaro didn’t just meet expectations; it significantly exceeded them, demonstrating that a legendary nameplate could evolve dramatically without losing its soul.

Lessons Learned from the 2016 COTY Competition

The 2016 Motor Trend Car of the Year competition offered several key insights into the automotive industry’s direction and the criteria that truly matter. It highlighted a period of significant transition and innovation.

• The Power of a Platform: The success of vehicles like the Camaro (sharing its Alpha platform with Cadillac) and the Honda Civic (all-new global platform) underscored the critical importance of a strong underlying architecture. A great platform can elevate a vehicle in every aspect, from driving dynamics to interior packaging.
• Balance of Performance and Efficiency: Many contenders, from the Civic with its new turbo engine to the Malibu’s hybrid option, showcased a dual focus on delivering engaging performance alongside improved fuel economy. The industry was clearly moving away from single-minded pursuits.
• Technology as a Differentiator: From the Audi TT’s Virtual Cockpit to the BMW 7 Series’ Gesture Control and the Toyota Mirai’s fuel cell, technology was a crucial battleground. However, the competition also showed that technology needs to be seamlessly integrated and genuinely enhance the user experience, not just exist for its own sake.
• Reinvention Over Evolution: The strongest contenders were those that weren’t afraid to completely reinvent themselves (Camaro, Civic) or introduce truly groundbreaking technology (Mirai). Incremental improvements, while valuable, often struggled to stand out against more radical transformations.

Based on my experience, what truly differentiates a COTY winner is not just excelling in one area, but demonstrating a balanced and significant leap forward across most, if not all, of the core criteria.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Judging a Car

For consumers and critics alike, evaluating a car can be complex. Here are some common pitfalls to steer clear of, ensuring a more objective and informed assessment:

• Focusing Solely on Horsepower: While power figures are exciting, they don’t tell the whole story. A car’s handling, braking, and the quality of its power delivery are often more crucial to the overall driving experience.
• Ignoring Long-Term Costs: Beyond the sticker price, consider fuel economy, insurance, maintenance, and potential depreciation. A seemingly affordable car can become expensive over its lifetime.
• Neglecting a Thorough Test Drive: Don’t just drive around the block. Take the car on various road types, including highways and city streets, to truly assess its comfort, performance, and features in real-world scenarios.
• Overlooking "Performance of Intended Function": Remember that a family SUV shouldn’t be judged solely on its track performance, nor should a sports car be expected to have minivan-like cargo space. Judge a car based on what it’s designed to do.
• Falling for Hype Without Substance: Marketing can be powerful, but always look beyond the glossy advertisements. Dig into independent reviews, long-term reliability reports, and critically assess if the car truly delivers on its promises.

Pro tips from us: always consider your personal needs and driving habits first. What’s "best" for one person might not be for another.

The Enduring Legacy of the 2016 Contenders

The cars that competed for the 2016 Motor Trend Car of the Year award left an indelible mark on the automotive landscape. The Chevrolet Camaro continued its reign as a modern performance icon, influencing subsequent generations of muscle cars. The Honda Civic’s bold redesign ushered in a new era for compact cars, proving that affordability doesn’t mean compromising on style or technology. The Mazda Miata reinforced the timeless appeal of a lightweight, pure sports car.

Even the Toyota Mirai, despite its niche market, paved the way for future hydrogen fuel cell development, showcasing the potential for zero-emission vehicles. The technological advancements introduced in the BMW 7 Series and Audi TT trickled down to more mainstream models, elevating the overall automotive experience. These vehicles, whether they won or not, pushed the industry forward, setting new benchmarks for design, engineering, and performance.

For those interested in how car awards evolve and impact the industry, you might enjoy our deep dive into "The History of Automotive Awards and Their Impact" . Understanding these historical contexts often illuminates current trends.

Conclusion: A Benchmark Year in Automotive Excellence

The 2016 Motor Trend Car of the Year competition was a truly memorable event, bringing together an extraordinary collection of vehicles that pushed the boundaries of automotive design, engineering, and performance. Each contender, from the audacious Toyota Mirai to the refined BMW 7 Series, brought something unique and valuable to the table, showcasing the diverse and innovative spirit of the automotive industry.

The ultimate victory of the Chevrolet Camaro was a testament to a comprehensive and successful reinvention, proving that even an iconic nameplate can evolve dramatically to meet modern demands. But beyond the winner, this year’s lineup provided invaluable insights into the trends shaping the future of mobility – from advanced powertrains and sophisticated chassis engineering to groundbreaking in-car technology.

As we look back, the 2016 contenders serve as a powerful reminder that true automotive excellence is a multifaceted achievement, combining aesthetic appeal, mechanical prowess, and a deep understanding of what drivers truly desire. It was a year that celebrated not just cars, but the relentless pursuit of perfection on four wheels. For those looking to understand the core elements of vehicle engineering, check out our article on ‘Understanding Automotive Platforms: From Sedans to Sports Cars’ .

For more detailed information on the 2016 Motor Trend Car of the Year awards and finalists, you can visit the official Motor Trend archives.